Wall Street Journal Examines HIPAA Loopholes

January 4, 2007 – 9:07 am | posted in Health Insurance, IT / Internet / E-mail, Primary Care, Public Health

“[I]ncreasingly complex confidentiality issues” in federal medical privacy rules “are affecting patients and their insurance coverage,” the Wall Street Journal reports. According to the Journal, complaints of privacy violations “have been piling up.” Between April 2003 and Nov. 30, 2006, HHS received 23,896 complaints related to medical-privacy rules. An HHS spokesperson said 75% of those complaints have been closed because no violations were found or informal guidance was provided to involved parties. Since HIPAA was enacted in 2003, HHS has not taken enforcement actions against any entity for violating the privacy rule. The Journal profiled attorney Patricia Galvin, who was denied disability benefits after her health insurer, UnumProvident, accessed notes from psychotherapy sessions at Stanford Hospital & Clinics. According to the Journal, UnumProvident said the notes indicated that Galvin was not “too injured to work” after she was involved in a car accident and applied for long-term disability leave. UnumProvident had asked Galvin to sign a broad release to access her basic medical records, which included some of the psychotherapist’s notes about Galvin that Stanford had scanned into its computer records system. Galvin has filed a lawsuit against Stanford and UnumProvident for violating medical privacy laws, among other issues, under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act. HIPAA includes added protection for mental health records, but Stanford in court papers said that “psychotherapy notes that are kept together with the patient’s other medical records are not defined as ‘psychotherapy’ notes under HIPAA.” Peter Swire, a law professor at Ohio State University who helped write the regulations, said, “We’re three years into the enforcement of the rule, and they haven’t brought their first enforcement initiative.” He added, “It sends the signal that the health system can ignore this issue” (Francis, Wall Street Journal, 12/26/06).

“Reprinted with permission from http://www.kaisernetwork.org. You can view the entire Kaiser Daily Health Policy Report, search the archives, or sign up for email delivery at http://www.kaisernetwork.org/dailyreports/healthpolicy. The Kaiser Daily Health Policy Report is published for kaisernetwork.org, a free service of The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation . © 2005 Advisory Board Company and Kaiser Family Foundation. All rights reserved.

ShareThis

Also Read

  • Wall Street Journal Examines Efforts By U.S. Hospitals To Improve Informed Consent Processes
  • GSK To Reduce Cost Of 14 Antiretrovirals Sold In Developing Nations
  • Wall Street Journal Examines ‘Period Management’ Options, Benefits, Risks
  • Wall Street Journal Profiles Women With Lupus To Highlight Difficulties In U.S. Health System
  • WSJ Examines Lack Of NIH Grants For ‘High-Risk’ Research
  • Google Partners With Cleveland Clinic To Allow Storage Of Patient Health Records Online
  • Wall Street Journal Examines Whether Women Should Take Aspirin To Prevent Heart Disease
  • Letter To Editor Criticizes Recent Wall Street Journal Opinion Piece Addressing SCHIP Legislation
  • Letter To The Editor Disputes Wall Street Journal Editorial Against SCHIP Expansion
  • Wall Street Journal Profiles Citizenship Problems For Family With Disabled Son

    • You must be logged in to post a comment.